The Participation Decision Almost Nobody Makes
Every physician, practitioner and supplier in Medicare has until December 31 to decide whether to participate in CY 2027. We counted how many walked away last time. In the whole CY2024 provider file, 1,020 of 1.3 million never took assignment on a single claim, and 814 of them are chiropractors.
Thursday's MLN Connects carried the reminder CMS sends every November. Physicians, practitioners and suppliers have until December 31 to decide whether to participate in Medicare for CY 2027.
It is a payer contract that renews itself by doing nothing. Take no action and your current status carries into January untouched.
So the annual window is less a decision than an invitation, which raises the question we actually wanted answered:
"Medicare hands 1.3 million providers a yearly chance to walk. How many take it?"
We counted the last complete year. 1,020.
Who Actually Says No
That number comes out of the CY2024 Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners by-Provider file, the most recent data year CMS has published, and the flag is stricter than it sounds. CMS sets the participation indicator to Y for any provider with at least one claim showing participation or accepted assignment, anywhere in the year, on any code in any place of service.
An N is a provider who never once took assignment. Out of 1,296,739 in the file, 1,020 cleared that bar.
Four in five of them adjust spines (chart below).

Chiropractic alone is 814. Physical therapists in private practice are 106, psychiatry 27, and every physician specialty in the file put together contributes 34: nine family practice, five dermatology, five internal medicine, one hospitalist, one rheumatologist, on down.
The shape has not moved in twelve years. In 2013 the holdouts numbered 956 and chiropractic was 751 of them, 78.6 percent against today's 79.8.
The count has sat between 859 and 1,020 every year since, against a file that grew by 340,488 providers over the same stretch.
What did move is 2024 itself. The count rose from 944 to 1,020, the first year above a thousand and the highest in the series, and 72 of those 76 additions were chiropractors.
What the 9.25 Percent Buys
The arithmetic behind the decision is two regulations deep, and the second one does the work.
414.20(b): the fee schedule amount for a nonparticipating supplier is 95 percent of the participating amount.414.48(b): the limiting charge is 115 percent of that number, the nonparticipating one.
So the ceiling a non-participating provider can bill a patient on an unassigned claim is 1.15 times 0.95, or 109.25 percent of what the participating provider down the street collects.
Run it on 98941, the three-to-four region spinal manipulation, at the CY 2027 conversion factor of $32.6286 CMS printed in Tuesday's relative value file.
Participating allowed: $37.85. Non-participating allowed: $35.96. Limiting charge: $41.35.
The whole prize is $3.50 a visit, before geographic adjustment.
And it does not come out of Medicare.
The patient hands over the full $41.35 and gets back 80 percent of the non-participating amount, $28.77, leaving them $12.58 out of pocket against the $7.57 they would owe a participating provider. Medicare's own check shrinks by $1.51.
You trade 80 percent from a payer for 100 percent from a household, on a $41 claim, and keep $3.50 of the difference.
Why It Is Chiropractic
410.21(b) is the reason. Medicare Part B pays a chiropractor for manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation, and for nothing else they furnish or order, X-rays included.
One covered service, priced at $26.43 to $49.27 across 98940, 98941 and 98942 for CY 2027.
Which makes the participation agreement a thin thing to sign.
The 814 non-participating chiropractors ran 250,682 services through Medicare in 2024 for $8.43 million allowed, about $33.61 a service and $10,351 a year each. The rest of their book was already cash.
The rates inside each specialty say the same thing louder:
- Chiropractic: 2.51 percent of all 32,394 in the file.
- Audiology: 0.14 percent. Psychiatry: 0.14 percent. Physical therapy: 0.14 percent.
- Optometry: 0.03 percent.
- Everyone, program-wide: 0.08 percent.
Chiropractic runs 17 times the next-highest specialty and 32 times the program rate. Nobody else is close, and the five dermatologists on the list, averaging $192,907 of Medicare allowed apiece, are the only holdouts with a book worth the name.
Final Thoughts
Put all 1,020 together and their entire Medicare business is $14.7 million allowed across 39,411 beneficiaries. The program will not notice them in January, and it did not notice them in any of the eleven Januaries before.
That is the honest answer to what the December 31 window is worth to a practice with real Part B volume. The exit exists, it is priced at 9.25 percent, and it is paid for by sending your patients a bill they used to read as a 20 percent coinsurance line.
CMS just cut the conversion factor another 2.31 percent for CY 2027, and twelve years of this file say the holdout count does not follow it anywhere.
Which is worth knowing before somebody in your group proposes it as a strategy this December.
Thanks for reading.