Downcoded

The $456 Per Beneficiary That Never Reached the Trust Fund

CMS reconciled performance year 2025 of the Shared Savings Program last Tuesday and called it a record on both sides: $4.9 billion to ACOs, $2.5 billion to Medicare. Gross savings per assigned beneficiary rose to $690 and Medicare's net fell to $234, which puts the ACO side of the split at $456 a head, up from $308 two years ago.


CMS reconciled performance year 2025 of the Shared Savings Program on November 17 and led with the two numbers it always leads with.

ACOs earned $4.9 billion in performance payments. Medicare saved $2.5 billion against benchmarks.

Both are program records, and 80 percent of the 472 participating ACOs took a payment, the highest share since the program started.

The agency prints a second pair of numbers further down, and that pair is the one that decides what the first pair means.

Gross per capita savings, which CMS defines as "the savings shared by ACOs and Medicare," came in at $690 per assigned beneficiary. Net per capita savings, "the savings for Medicare only," came in at $234.

Subtract and you have the ACO side of the line: $456 a head, against $402 in PY2024 and $308 in PY2023 (chart below).

Gross went up every year. Medicare's slice went down every year, from 40.2% of gross to 37.5% to 33.9%, and in PY2025 it went down in dollars as well, off $7 a head while gross rose $47.

"Who is actually capturing the record savings year?"

CMS Says Why in One Clause

The fact sheet does not bury the cause. The decline in net per capita savings "represents more ACOs moving into two-sided risk tracks (a 4 percentage point increase between PY 2024 and PY 2025), and ACOs participating in two-sided tracks are eligible for higher shared savings rates and, therefore, can retain more of the savings they earned."

So the mechanism is deliberate and the direction is the one CMS designed for. A four-point migration into downside risk is a small move in participation and a visible one in the split.

The rest of this brief is for subscribers.

The impact tables, the code-level detail, and the rest of the analysis sit past this line.

$50 a month, or $500 a year.