The $90 Billion Your MA Plans Have to Find in Your Charts
CMS filed a 545-page program integrity proposed rule at 4:15 this afternoon. The Office of the Actuary has not scored it, and the impact tables still book $90.2 billion of Medicare Advantage RADV recoveries from 2027 to 2036. The whole figure is one multiplication: $37.6 million found on 29,900 sampled enrollees a decade ago, divided to $1,258 a head, times 71.7 million enrollees who were never reviewed.
Medicare audited Medicare Advantage contracts for payment years 2011 through 2015 and found $37.6 million in improper payments across 29,900 sampled enrollees.
Those audits closed without extrapolation. The rule that would have extrapolated them, finalized in February 2023, was vacated by a federal judge in the Northern District of Texas on September 25, 2025.
At 4:15 this afternoon CMS filed the replacement.
CMS-6098-P, Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, runs 545 pages across eleven parts of 42 CFR and one of 45. It publishes Thursday. The Office of the Actuary, by CMS's own admission, "has not completed a quantitative score of the Federal budgetary or trust fund impacts."
The impact tables still carry a number.
"Where does a ten-year, $90 billion recovery estimate come from when the actuary has not scored the rule?"
What CMS Scheduled
Table C-B5 lays the recoveries out year by year, and the shape is the first thing worth reading.
$2.2 billion in 2027. Then $16.8 billion in each of 2028 and 2029, $13.6 billion in 2030, and a flat $6.79 billion a year through 2036 (chart below).

The grey series is the counterfactual CMS printed beside it. Audits run under today's rules collect $439.1 million across the entire decade.
That is a factor of 205 between the two columns of the same table.
And the single RADV row is effectively the whole rule. Total transfers across all 545 pages come to $90.23 billion, and the MA RADV line is $90.17 billion of it.
Everything else, the Medicaid payment suspensions, the state NPI requirements, the managed care oversight reporting, the PERM corrective action plans, nets to about $63 million.
(Two tables disagree by $0.2 million on the ten-year total. The column sums to $90,166.1 million, which is what Table C-B8 prints; C-B5 and C-B6 both print $90,166.3 million.)
The rest of this brief is for subscribers.
The impact tables, the code-level detail, and the rest of the analysis sit past this line.
$50 a month, or $500 a year.
Already a subscriber? Sign in