Who Is Supervising 3.8 Million Medicare Anesthesia Cases?
CMS reopened the CRNA physician-supervision requirement on Tuesday, twenty-five years after it last tried to settle the question and twenty-six governors took their states out of it anyway. We ran the CY2025 claims file against the question. The arrangement Medicare pays for most often already has no physician directing it, 3,769,986 cases and $585.3 million, and nothing CMS does with this RFI moves the modifier that says so.
In January 2001 CMS finalized a rule letting state law decide who administers anesthesia and under what level of supervision.
That rule never took effect. Its effective date got pushed 60 days, then another 180, and in July 2001 CMS proposed a different mechanism entirely: a governor could write a letter and exempt the whole state. The second proposal drew 28,500 comments on top of the first one's 20,000, and the November 13, 2001 final rule kept physician supervision in place with the governor's letter as the escape hatch.
Twenty-six governors and one territory have since written that letter.
On Tuesday CMS put the whole arrangement back up for comment.
"Does the current supervision and exemption policy provide sufficient flexibility to States to opt out of the federal supervision requirements or is the policy excessively burdensome?"
That question sits at 91 FR 72695, inside CMS-3484-P, the deregulation rule that published Tuesday at 91 FR 72634. Comments close January 11, 2027, docket CMS-2026-3631.
We went and asked the claims file what it thought.
The rest of this brief is for subscribers.
The impact tables, the code-level detail, and the rest of the analysis sit past this line.
$50 a month, or $500 a year.
Already a subscriber? Sign in